Elon Musk is wrong about Orwell says Jean Seaton

Professor Jean Seaton, director of the Orwell Foundation and official historian for the BBC, has strongly criticized Elon Musk’s interpretation of George Orwell’s work. In response to Musk’s recent social media post invoking Orwell, Seaton expressed her dismay at what she calls a “terrible ripping out of context and complexity and nuance” of the author’s writings.

Seaton argues that Musk and other right-wing figures have fundamentally misunderstood Orwell’s message. She emphasizes that Orwell was not against all forms of government, but specifically warned against totalitarian regimes. The professor contends that Orwell would not have supported unrestricted free speech, especially if it led to real-world violence.

According to Seaton, Orwell was a “reality fundamentalist” rather than a “free speech fundamentalist”. She points to Orwell’s own words, where he described his work as being “against totalitarianism and for democratic socialism”. Seaton suggests that Orwell’s famous quote about freedom being “the freedom to say that two plus two make four” is about the importance of acknowledging incontrovertible facts, not about promoting unfettered opinion.

The Orwell Foundation director expresses concern over the widespread misinterpretation of Orwell’s work, particularly by those who have not read his writings in full. She proposes a simple solution to this problem: encouraging people to read Orwell’s works directly, rather than relying on others’ interpretations.

Read the full article on the Metro Website.

Photo by Ethan Rougon on Unsplash