Steven Barnett: Ofcom is not doing its job on impartiality

0
architecture-architecture-london-a591236ffd922e7e984fc6369a0cd250

Professor Steven Barnett has written for the Media Society Substack. He argues that Ofcom is failing to apply the law on broadcasting impartiality, and that the government should now step in.

The piece starts with an exchange at the House of Commons Culture, Media and Sport select committee last month. Rupa Huq MP asked Ofcom’s new chair, Sir Ian Cheshire, whether the regulator was being too lenient with GB News. Sir Ian replied that critics such as Stewart Purvis and Alan Rusbridger could set up “a left-wing version of GB News”. Steven says the answer seems to admit that GB News is a right-wing channel. More seriously, he says it suggests a misunderstanding of the Communications Act 2003. Section 320 of the Act sets special impartiality requirements for programmes on “matters of political or industrial controversy” and “matters relating to current public policy”.

Steven looks at the two main reasons Ofcom gives for not acting. The first is its distinction between “news” and “current affairs”, which lets serving politicians present current affairs programmes. He calls this a distinction the regulator invented and one that does not exist in law. He points to a week-long content analysis of GB News evening programmes by Stewart Purvis and Chris Banatvala, which found that 39 of the 42 subjects covered were news events of the day. He also cites a recent Demos report covering 37 European media regulators. Apart from the UK, only Iceland and Malta reported serving politicians presenting news or current affairs.

The second reason is freedom of expression. Steven says this wrongly assumes that free speech and impartiality are in conflict. European Court of Human Rights case law allows limits on expression that are “necessary in a democratic society”. A 2020 High Court judgment on RT’s challenge to an Ofcom sanction also found that impartiality is essential to the quality of political discourse.

The article notes that Culture Secretary Lisa Nandy has said the government intends to act. It also notes that MPs criticised Ofcom’s record on broadcasting standards in a recent Westminster Hall debate. Steven concludes that a small amendment to the Communications Act would remove any ambiguity and oblige Ofcom to enforce the law, and he calls on the Culture Secretary to bring it forward now.

Steven is Professor of Communications at the University of Westminster. He has worked in communications policy analysis for 35 years and has advised several parliamentary committees. This year he was specialist adviser to the Commons Culture, Media and Sport select committee for its inquiry into BBC Charter Renewal, which reported on 1 October 2026.

Read the full article on the Media Society Substack; https://themediasociety.substack.com/p/ofcom-is-not-doing-its-job-on-impartiality

 

Image: PickPik

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *